Our Good hiring matters research shows that the consequences of getting workforce decisions wrong are significant. Unfilled vacancies and bad hires cost UK businesses an estimated £99.4 billion a year, affecting productivity, adding pressure for existing teams and curbing organisational growth.
Good hiring combines a clear understanding of workforce needs and the labour market with sound professional judgement and high professional standards. It means making informed decisions about the people and skills an organisation needs, recognising potential as well as experience and ensuring candidates are treated fairly and professionally throughout.
That starts long before a vacancy appears. In a labour market being reshaped by AI, demographic change and shifting skills needs, leaders need to understand the capabilities their organisation will need, how jobs are changing and where technology and professional expertise can help them make better decisions with confidence.
Start with workforce strategy
The first question should not always be: who do we need to hire?
It should be: what capability does the organisation need to deliver its strategy?
Businesses need a clear view of the skills and capacity they have today, where future gaps are likely to emerge and which capabilities will be critical to growth. From there, leaders can make informed choices about whether to recruit, develop existing people, redesign work, bring in temporary or specialist expertise, or use technology differently.
This matters because leaving a role unfilled is itself a business decision with big implications.
Our research estimates that unfilled vacancies cost UK businesses £72.8 billion in 2025. Beyond the direct impact on output, existing employees take on greater workloads, opportunities may be delayed and organisations can find themselves operating below capacity.
The question for leaders is therefore not simply what does it cost to hire but what is the opportunity cost of waiting? They need to factor in what could the organisation be delivering, changing or growing if it had the right capability in place.
AI is reshaping workforce needs
Much of the conversation about AI and recruitment has focused on how technology can make hiring processes faster. But the bigger strategic question is what AI means for the work itself.
As technology takes on more tasks, jobs will evolve. Some activities will be automated, others augmented and different skills and capabilities will become more valuable.
A vacancy therefore creates an opportunity to ask whether a role should simply be replaced like for like. What should the job look like now? How could it evolve over the next few years? Where will human capability create the greatest value alongside technology?
Good workforce planning increasingly means aligning business and technology strategies to enable better job design, skills development and recruitment.
Labour market insight builds hiring confidence
Hiring will always involve risk. But uncertainty does not have to mean paralysis. Employers can build confidence by combining workforce data, labour market intelligence, professional judgement and by drawing on the skills of experienced recruitment professionals.
Understanding whether the skills you need are available, where they are, what they cost and what candidates expect gives leaders better evidence on which to act. It can also show when the answer is to rethink the role, develop skills internally or take a more flexible approach to accessing talent.
Professional recruiters have an important role here. Their understanding of candidate markets can help organisations test assumptions about skills, salary, location and availability. When treated as long-term partners, they can develop a deeper understanding of an organisation’s strategy, values and culture, helping to identify not only candidates with the right experience, but people with the potential and approach to succeed in that environment.
That expertise is most valuable when recruiters are involved in future workforce planning, rather than brought in only when an individual vacancy needs to be filled.
Confidence also needs the right environment
Individual businesses cannot solve every workforce challenge alone.
Good hiring depends on organisations being able to access skills in different ways, from permanent recruitment and internal development to temporary and flexible work. It also depends on an economic and regulatory environment that gives employers confidence to invest in people.
As government implements the Employment Rights Act and pursues its wider growth and Industrial Strategy ambitions, getting that balance right matters. Effective protections for workers must sit alongside a flexible labour market in which employers have the confidence to create opportunities, recruit and grow.
Changes to unfair dismissal protection will make it even more important to get hiring, onboarding and early performance management right. Employers should use probation periods effectively, with clear expectations, regular feedback and timely action where support or improvement is needed. Managers will have a critical role in giving new hires the direction and support they need to succeed.
Access to the right talent is not separate from the growth agenda. It is fundamental to delivering it.
Use AI responsibly and expect high professional standards
Technology should help us make better decisions, not simply faster ones.
As AI plays a greater role in recruitment, employers and recruiters need to understand how it is being used, ensure the data and criteria behind it are appropriate and that unintended bias is not introduced or reinforced. It's essential to retain meaningful human oversight of decisions that affect people’s experience of the hiring process and access to work.
And greater automation should raise the bar for the candidate experience.
If technology makes it possible to communicate efficiently at scale, every candidate should receive a response to an application. Candidates who have invested significant time in interviews or assessments should expect meaningful feedback.
Technology should support higher professional standards, not lower them.
For REC members, this sits alongside the commitments in our professional Code of Practice: to act with integrity, treat candidates fairly and deliver high professional standards.
Good hiring is a business imperative
Getting hiring right is not simply an HR or recruitment issue. Workforce decisions determine whether organisations have the people and skills to execute their strategy, adopt new technology, respond to opportunities and grow.
There will rarely be a completely risk-free moment to hire. The objective is to have the evidence, expertise and confidence to make the right workforce decisions at the right time.
Good hiring matters, and the recruitment and talent industry has a vital role to play. The REC and its members are helping set the standard for what good hiring looks like.
Download the full report