Alan Milburn Review: what recruiters need to know
Government and campaigns
Today, the government published the long-awaited final report of the Alan Milburn review: From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation.
The review estimates that around 500,000 additional employment and education opportunities may be needed by 2036 to achieve its ambition for full youth participation.
Its proposals also include a targeted employer incentive package expected to create an additional 170,000 job and apprenticeship opportunities.
The REC shares the government's ambition to widen access to opportunity for young people and ensure more can find a route into employment.
Delivering this ambition will require businesses to create significantly more opportunities for young people. The REC will continue calling on government to create more favourable market conditions for job creation, making it easier, less costly and less risky for employers to hire.
If the recommendations are accepted, the report represents an opportunity for REC members to work more closely with clients on their youth employment programmes including training and the facilitation of work experience.
Guaranteed Hours and protecting temporary work
Of particular importance to REC members is the review's consideration of Guaranteed Hours legislation.
Milburn says the impact on youth employment should be a primary consideration when the government considers responses to its consultation and recommends adopting a cautionary principle. He argues that implementation should aim to limit the potential negative impact on seasonal and temporary work, while balancing the need to reduce one-sided flexibility with retaining a dynamic and flexible labour market.
The review does not recommend a specific exemption for recruitment agencies which is what the REC’s primary ask is. However, Milburn has opened the door on the government re-assessing their plans based on the impact on youth employment which is very welcome and something the REC had encouraged Milburn to take account of.
If the government accepts Milburn's recommendation to protect temporary and seasonal work, we will be making the case that this must include an exemption for genuinely temporary agency work.
Recognition of recruitment agencies
The report explicitly recognises the role employment agencies play in meeting employers' needs for shorter-term and flexible staffing, particularly for SMEs. It also acknowledges that agency work can offer young people valuable opportunities and variety.
It proposes exploring an expansion of the existing Flexible Job Apprenticeship Agency (FJAA) model through the new Youth Opportunity Service. This could enable agencies to support smaller businesses with recruitment, payroll, administration and pastoral support, making it easier for them to offer young people employment and apprenticeship opportunities.
Several of our members are already part of the FJAA model. We welcome the recognition of the important role agencies can play in helping young people enter the workforce and supporting employers to recruit.
Other proposals for employers
There are several other recommendations relevant to REC members:
-
Youth Jobs Grant: Expand the £3,000 grant for employers recruiting 16–24-year-olds who have been NEET for at least six months, regardless of whether they claim benefits. Add £2,000 premiums for employers hiring young people facing significant barriers and for businesses with fewer than 50 employees.
-
Jobs Guarantee: Bring forward eligibility for a six-month subsidised job for young people who have been out of work from 18 months to 12 months.
-
Employer National Insurance: Introduce a five-year glide path, when fiscal conditions allow, to reduce employer NI costs for 21–24-year-olds, initially in retail and hospitality, by increasing the earnings threshold from £5,000 to £10,000.
-
Apprenticeships: Increase the employer hiring incentive from £2,000 to £2,500 and extend it to levy-paying employers, alongside a new £2,000 incentive for training providers. The review also sets an ambition for 270,000 under-25 apprenticeship starts each year by 2036.
-
First Chance: Scale up an employer-led movement to create more “genuine first jobs” (paid entry-level roles that give young people without previous work experience a meaningful route into employment), alongside more apprenticeships and work experience. Large employers are encouraged to set their own targets, including potentially making 10% of entry-level vacancies available to young people who are NEET.
The government must now turn the review's recommendations into practical policy and work with employers and the recruitment industry on implementation. We look forward to working with the government on this.
Share this article